Skip to content

The Toy Store - 2900 E Lincolnway - Sterling IL - 815-622-5996

Home
Special Buys
Shop By Age
Categories
- Accessories
  
  All Accessories
  Pins and Stickers
  Purses
  Tumblers and Cups
- Arts & Crafts
- Bath Toys
- Building Toys & Blocks
- Cards
- Dolls
  
  All Dolls
  Assorted Dolls
  Baby Stella
  18 Inch Dolls
- Dungeons and Dragons
  
  All Dungeons and Dragons
  Dice
  Accessories
- Figurines
- Fidget Toys
  
  All Fidget Toys
  Squishies
  Slime
- Impulse
- Remote Control Toys
- Ride On Toys & Bikes
- Science & STEM Kits
- Trucks and Cars
- Outdoor Toys
- Tonies
  
  All Tonies
  TonieBoxes
  Tonies Accessories
- Toddler Toys
Brands We Love
- HALFTOYS
- HABA
- Fat Brain
- Squishable
  
  All Squishables
  Original Squish
  Mini Squish
  Micro Squish
  Squishable Go
  Undercover Squish
- Warmies
- Tonies
  
  All Tonies Products
  Tonie Boxes
  Tonies Accessories
- Wow Toys
Balloons
Books
Candy
Home and Decor
Games and Puzzles
- All Games and Puzzles
- Games
  
  All Games
  3+ to 6+
  7+ to 11+
  12+
- Puzzle Games
- Jigsaw Puzzles
  
  All Puzzles
  150 Pieces and Under
  500 Pieces and Under
  1000 Pieces and Under
Outdoor Toys
Plush
- All Plush
- Squishables
  
  All Squishables
  Micro Squish
  Mini Squish
  Original Squish
  Massive Squish
  Undercovers
  Squishable Go!
- Warmies
Fundraiser Prize Catalog

Facebook
Instagram
TikTok

Search

The Toy Store - Unplug & Play

Home
Special Buys
Shop By Age
Categories
- Accessories
  
  All Accessories
  Pins and Stickers
  Purses
  Tumblers and Cups
- Arts & Crafts
- Bath Toys
- Building Toys & Blocks
- Cards
- Dolls
  
  All Dolls
  Assorted Dolls
  Baby Stella
  18 Inch Dolls
- Dungeons and Dragons
  
  All Dungeons and Dragons
  Dice
  Accessories
- Figurines
- Fidget Toys
  
  All Fidget Toys
  Squishies
  Slime
- Impulse
- Remote Control Toys
- Ride On Toys & Bikes
- Science & STEM Kits
- Trucks and Cars
- Outdoor Toys
- Tonies
  
  All Tonies
  TonieBoxes
  Tonies Accessories
- Toddler Toys
Brands We Love
- HALFTOYS
- HABA
- Fat Brain
- Squishable
  
  All Squishables
  Original Squish
  Mini Squish
  Micro Squish
  Squishable Go
  Undercover Squish
- Warmies
- Tonies
  
  All Tonies Products
  Tonie Boxes
  Tonies Accessories
- Wow Toys
Balloons
Books
Candy
Home and Decor
Games and Puzzles
- All Games and Puzzles
- Games
  
  All Games
  3+ to 6+
  7+ to 11+
  12+
- Puzzle Games
- Jigsaw Puzzles
  
  All Puzzles
  150 Pieces and Under
  500 Pieces and Under
  1000 Pieces and Under
Outdoor Toys
Plush
- All Plush
- Squishables
  
  All Squishables
  Micro Squish
  Mini Squish
  Original Squish
  Massive Squish
  Undercovers
  Squishable Go!
- Warmies
Fundraiser Prize Catalog

Search

Item added to your cart

View cart

Your cart

Continue shopping

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Have an account?

Log in to check out faster.

Loading...

Order special instructions

Estimated total

$0.00 USD

Taxes, Discounts and shipping calculated at checkout

Quick links

Search
Contact
FAQ

Subscribe to our emails

Email

Facebook
Instagram
TikTok

Payment methods

© 2026, The Toy Store - Unplug & Play Powered by Shopify

Refund policy
Privacy policy
Terms of service
Shipping policy
Contact information

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.